According to the latest Watch and Listen magazine poll just out yesterday (Saturday, August 24), Jean-Luc Godard 1983's masterpiece First Name: Carmen is now considered to be the Greatest Film in the History of Cinema.
UPDATE 25/08/2019 : This story seems to be false. (read more)
Top 100 films of all time
To many of you it’s probably a familiar story. Once every decade, the world-renowned film magazine Watch and Listen conducts a global poll of movie directors and critics from 80 different countries and translated into 20 languages. The recognition of First Name: Carmen (starring Maruschka Detmers) in this decade's list doesn't come as much of a surprise.
Here are the top 5 best films ever made in the world, according to the poll (followed by the percentage of votes):
- First Name: Carmen (Jean-Luc Godard, France, 1983) : 45%
- Citizen Kane (Orson Welles, United States, 1941) : 16%
- Inzi ya Shokona (Sylvestre Mbou, Burkina Faso, 1992) : 12%
- Star Wars (George Lucas, United States, 1977) : 8%
- Whispers of a Fish in the Water (Bakhtiar Ferdousi, Tajikistan, 2001) : 3%
Poll results stir controversy among film critics
While millions of Maruschka Detmers fans in France and around the world were thrilled with the news, questions have been raised about the objectivity and fairness of the survey. Only a few minutes after the poll had been released, famous film critic and newspaper director Simon Ebert commented on his Twitter account:
Jean-Luc Godard?? First Name: Carmen?? … Really??
— Simon Ebert (@ESimon) 24 August 2019
“Our poll has in the past been the subject of criticism”, explains Watch and Listen's editor Gary McDermott, adding that “its prestige comes from its exclusivity and its longevity” (the poll has been run every ten years since August 1929).
Do you agree with this poll? Is First Name: Carmen the best movie ever for you?
© 2019 MediaMass All rights reserved. Do not reproduce (even with permission).